5th October 2024 (8 Topics)
1
Oct
2
Oct
3
Oct
4
Oct
5
Oct
Caste in Jail: On discrimination in Prisons
You must be logged in to get greater insights. click here to login
Context
The Supreme Court recently issued a landmark ruling prohibiting caste-based discrimination in prison treatment, addressing longstanding colonial practices and constitutional violations in Indian jails.
Historical Context
- Colonial Legacy: The Court highlighted that the prison system has perpetuated colonial-era practices linked to caste, which influenced labor allocation, food preparation, and prisoner treatment.
- Caste Hierarchy in Prisons: Menial tasks were disproportionately assigned to lower-caste prisoners, while higher-caste individuals maintained privileges, reflecting a direct correlation to caste-based discrimination.
- Untouchability Violations: Provisions mandating food preparation by prisoners from "suitable castes" and tasks assigned based on caste undermined constitutional prohibitions against untouchability.
Constitutional Implications
- Rights to Dignity: The Court asserted that caste-based labor distribution violates the right to dignity, compelling prisoners into degrading roles based solely on birth.
- Forced Labor Concerns: Rules facilitating manual scavenging and other menial tasks contravene constitutional protections against forced labor and exploitation, raising serious ethical concerns.
- Criminalization of Caste: The Court criticized the vague classification of 'habitual offenders,' which ascribed criminal tendencies to entire communities, perpetuating harmful stereotypes.
Call to Action
- Urgent Revisions Required: State governments are mandated to revise prison manuals within three months, aligning with the constitutional objective of equality and non-discrimination.
- Systemic Discrimination: There is a pressing need to eliminate systemic discrimination in prisons, which often labels resistance as indiscipline rather than acknowledging the rights of prisoners.
- Reassessment of Laws: State authorities must critically reassess existing laws and practices regarding prison administration to foster an equitable environment for all inmates.
Practice Question
Q. Critically analyze the Supreme Court's recent ruling against caste-based discrimination in prisons. Discuss its implications for prison administration and constitutional rights in India.
Courses
Study
Notes
Home
Resources
More
