What's New :
29th July 2024 (12 Topics)

Tragic Safety Lapses in Educational Institutes

Context

Four civil services aspirants (numbers not confirmed) tragically lost their lives at a coaching center in central Delhi's Old Rajinder Nagar area due to the absence of drainage systems and safety measures. The center had also violated norms by using the basement for commercial activities, contributing to this unfortunate incident.

Not the first time

Several recent incidents highlight significant safety failures in educational institutes and hostels across India. These tragedies, involving fires and structural deficiencies, underscore the urgent need for enhanced safety measures to protect students.

List of unfortunate incidents

May 2019: Surat Fire Tragedy

 

  • Incident: A fire erupted due to a spark in an air conditioner, spreading rapidly due to highly inflammable materials.
  • Casualties: 22 students died, mostly due to suffocation or jumping off the building.
  • Issues: Lack of fire safety measures, including proper exits and fire alarms.
  • Aftermath: Legal actions initiated against responsible individuals; ongoing demands for faster justice from victims' families.

January 2023: Pune Educational Institute Fire

  • Incident: Early morning fire led to the death of hostel manager; lack of fire safety measures contributed to chaos.
  • Evacuation: Students escaped using a ladder to an adjacent building.

June 2023: Mukherjee Nagar Fire Incident

 

  • Incident: Fire started in the electricity meter, causing panic among students.
  • Response: Students escaped through windows and wires, resulting in injuries and casualties.
  • Concerns: Inadequate safety measures despite prompt fire brigade response.

April 2024: Kota Hostel Fire

 

  • Incident: Short circuit in a transformer led to a fire; hostel lacked fire safety equipment and emergency exits.
  • Consequences: Seven students injured while attempting to flee; authorities booked hostel management for negligence.

What factors are responsible?

  • Common Issues: Lack of fire exits, poor ventilation, inadequate fire safety equipment (alarms, hydrants, smoke detectors).
  • Regulatory Failures: Despite safety regulations in place, enforcement remains lax, contributing to recurring incidents.
  • Safety Negligence and Urban Challenges: The tragedy has brought to light deep-rooted issues plaguing urban areas across India. The incident underscores a systemic failure in ensuring safety standards and highlights broader concerns such as corruption, illegal urbanization, overcrowding, and the pursuit of financial gain at the expense of public safety.
  • Illegal Urbanization and Safety Violations: Rapid and unplanned urbanization has led to the illegal conversion of residential spaces into commercial ventures like coaching centers, often without adherence to building codes and safety norms. Basements, meant for utilities or parking, are frequently used for profit-making activities despite lacking proper ventilation, fire exits, or adequate safety measures.
  • Poor-implementation: The absence of uniform safety legislation and the NBC being a “recommendatory document,“ its provisions are frequently ignored at the local level. 
Accountability in Such Incidents
  • Responsibility of Educational Institutes: Educational institutes, including coaching centers and hostels, bear primary responsibility for ensuring the safety of their students. This includes:
    • Infrastructure: Providing adequate fire exits, proper ventilation, and fire safety equipment such as alarms, hydrants, and smoke detectors.
    • Compliance: Strict adherence to safety norms and regulations prescribed by local authorities.
    • Emergency Preparedness: Conducting regular safety audits and ensuring staff and students are trained in emergency procedures.
  • State's Responsibility: State authorities play a crucial role in ensuring safety standards are enforced and maintained:
    • Regulation: Implementing and enforcing stringent safety regulations applicable to educational institutes.
    • Inspections: Conducting regular inspections to assess compliance with safety standards.
    • Legal Oversight: Taking prompt legal action against institutes found negligent in adhering to safety norms.
What measures are required?
  • Safety Compliance: Coaching institutes must ensure all safety measures are in place as per regulatory requirements.
  • Transparency: There is need to provide clear information to students and parents about safety protocols and emergency procedures.
  • Calls for Action: There is urgent need for rigorous safety audits, strict adherence to safety norms, and swift legal actions against negligent institutions.
  • Student Safety: Government must ensure robust safety infrastructure is crucial to prevent further tragedies and protect students pursuing education away from home.
Fact Box: Building codes and safety norms
  • National Building Code (NBC): This comprehensive building Code is a national instrument providing guidelines for regulating building construction activities across the country. 
    • It was published by the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) in 1970 and last updated in 2016.
    • It serves as a Model Code for adoption by all agencies involved in building construction works, be they Public Works Departments, other government construction departments, local bodies, or private construction agencies. 
  • Delhi Building Bye Law: Every basement shall be in every part at least 2.4 m in height from the floor to the underside of the roof slab or ceiling. Adequate ventilation shall be provided for the basement. The standard of ventilation shall be the same as required by the particular occupancy according to Bye-laws.
  • Model Building Bye Laws 2016: It guides the States and UTs to frame their respective building bylaws. The Model also prescribes norms for fire protection and safety requirements.
Conclusion 

These incidents serve as stark reminders of the critical need to prioritize student safety in educational settings. Authorities must implement stringent measures and ensure compliance with safety regulations to prevent such avoidable disasters in the future.

Verifying, please be patient.

Enquire Now