20th September 2025 (16 Topics)
1
Sep
2
Sep
3
Sep
4
Sep
5
Sep
6
Sep
8
Sep
9
Sep
10
Sep
11
Sep
12
Sep
13
Sep
15
Sep
16
Sep
17
Sep
18
Sep
19
Sep
20
Sep
22
Sep
23
Sep
24
Sep
25
Sep
26
Sep
27
Sep
29
Sep
30
Sep
SC/ST Act and Anticipatory Bail
Context:
Supreme Court quashed Bombay High Court’s anticipatory bail order in Kiran vs Rajkumar Jivaraj Jain, reinforcing the bar on anticipatory bail under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
Supreme Court Reaffirms Legislative Intent
Background of the Case
- Incident:A Scheduled Caste member, alleged assault, caste abuse, sexual molestation of family members, looting, and threat with petrol in retaliation for not following voting directives.
- Procedural History:
- Sessions Court rejected anticipatory bail, citing casteist intent.
- Bombay High Court reversed, terming the case politically motivated and granted bail.
- Supreme Court intervened on appeal.
Legal Framework
- SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989:
- Section 18bars anticipatory bail for offences under the Act.
- Section 3(1)(r): Assaults or insults in public view counted as offences.
- Section 3(1)(o): Criminalizes coercion or retaliation for SC/ST voting choices.
- CrPC Reference: Section 438 (anticipatory bail) not applicable due to statutory bar.
- Constitutional Validation: Bar upheld under Article 14 (Equality) and Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty).
Supreme Court Observations
- High Courts cannot conduct “mini-trials” at bail stage; only prima facie case is examined.
- Offences outside complainant’s home, in public view, fulfill statutory requirement.
- Electoral retaliation against SC/ST voters carries broader democratic implications.
- Evidence such as witness accounts, medical reports, and recovery of weapons strengthened prosecution.
Analysis and Way Forward
- Legal Significance:
- Reinforces protective intent of SC/ST Act; prevents intimidation of marginalised communities.
- Courts must strictly apply prima facie test without slipping into evidentiary evaluation.
- Social and Democratic Implications:
- Upholds the dignity and safety of SC/ST communities.
- Protects electoral rights of marginalized voters, discouraging caste-based coercion.
More Articles
Courses
Study
Notes
Home
Resources
More