What's New :
IAS 2025: Target PT Prelims Classes and Tests. Get Details
21st May 2024 (15 Topics)

Another Crash, another High Profile Passenger

You must be logged in to get greater insights.

Context

The fatal crash of a Bell 212 helicopter, carrying Iran's President Ebrahim Raisi and Foreign Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian, highlights ongoing concerns about the safety of VVIP flights, especially in challenging weather conditions and mountainous terrains.

Recurring VVIP Flight Incidents (Historical Examples of Crashes)

  • Indian Incidents: The crash of the Bell helicopter in 2009, which killed Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y.S. Rajasekhara Reddy, and the 2021 crash that claimed General Bipin Rawat, both involved poor weather and hilly terrains.
  • International Incidents: The 2010 crash of the Polish President’s plane in Russia and the 2024 crash involving Iran’s President share common factors of adverse weather conditions leading to fatal accidents.
  • Pilot Pressure: Pilots often face pressure to fly in unsafe conditions from influential passengers, compromising their ability to make safety-first decisions.

Technological and Navigational Challenges (Impact of Weather and Navigation)

  • Visual Illusions: Adverse weather like fog and heavy rain can cause visual illusions, affecting pilots' depth perception and judgement.
  • GPS and Datum Shifts: Navigation errors due to differing datum systems, such as India’s EVER-MD versus the global WGS 84, can lead to catastrophic outcomes, as seen in incidents like the Balakot airstrike.
  • Advanced Technology Limitations: Even with advanced navigation systems like GPS, discrepancies in data input can significantly impact flight safety.

Safety Attitudes and Regulatory Failures

  • US Safety Standards: In the U.S., thorough investigations and transparent reporting, like the Aspen crash in Colorado, have led to improved safety measures and training.
  • Regulatory Issues: Repeated safety violations and oversight failures by aviation authorities contribute to recurring accidents.
  • Need for Pilot Autonomy: The critical importance of allowing pilots to make final decisions regarding flight safety without being overruled by VVIP passengers is emphasized to prevent future disasters.
Mains Question:

Discuss the recurring safety issues associated with VVIP flights in adverse weather conditions, highlighting international and Indian examples.

Verifying, please be patient.

Enquire Now