21st May 2024 (15 Topics)
1
May
2
May
3
May
4
May
6
May
7
May
8
May
9
May
10
May
11
May
13
May
14
May
15
May
16
May
17
May
18
May
20
May
21
May
22
May
23
May
24
May
25
May
27
May
28
May
29
May
30
May
31
May
A Better Do-Good Metric
You must be logged in to get greater insights. click here to login
Context
Re-evaluation of ESG Frameworks: The relevance and effectiveness of ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) metrics are being scrutinized as major firms like BlackRock move away from the acronym, highlighting potential shortcomings in the current ESG evaluation system.
Evolution and Importance of ESG (Historical Background)
- Origin: The ESG concept was launched in a 2005 UN report titled ‘Who Cares Wins,’ urging financial markets to promote sustainable practices.
- Global Adoption: ESG principles have become integral to the corporate world, with sustainable investments now comprising over a third of global assets.
- Regulatory and Investment Impetus: ESG ratings help companies secure their future, conform to regulatory demands, and attract investments aimed at reducing financial risks and promoting planetary well-being.
Challenges and Criticisms of ESG
- Lack of Uniformity: ESG metrics lack standardization, leading to credibility issues, with ratings from different agencies aligning only about half the time.
- Single Materiality Focus: Current ESG ratings often measure risks to a company from external factors rather than the company’s impact on the environment and society.
- Bundled Evaluation Issues: Combining E, S, and G into a single metric can yield paradoxical outcomes, as seen with the exclusion of Tesla from certain sustainability indices despite its low emissions.
Calls for Reform and Focus (Rethinking ESG Priorities)
- Separation of ESG Elements: There is a growing consensus on the need to prioritize emissions reduction separately from social and governance concerns to address critical environmental challenges more effectively.
- Critique and Recommendations: Critics argue that ESG, as currently structured, may avoid addressing significant issues like climate change and inequality, suggesting a focused approach on emission reductions for better outcomes.
Mains Question:
Critically analyze the challenges associated with ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) evaluations and suggest how these frameworks can be reformed to address contemporary global issues more effectively.
More Articles
Courses
Study
Notes
Home
Resources
More
