A Narrow Resolution

Context:

Pakistan's resolution at the United Nations to combat Islamophobia has sparked controversy and raised concerns about discrimination against other religions.

UN Resolution on Islamophobia:

• Objection: Pakistan's push for an "International Day to Combat Islamophobia" at the UN faced objections from countries like India, who argued against singling out one religion.
• Approval: Despite objections, the UN declared March 15 as the day to combat Islamophobia and approved the appointment of a special envoy to address the issue.
• Neglecting discrimination against others: Critics argue that the UN's focus on Islamophobia neglects discrimination faced by followers of other religions and undermines the principle of religious neutrality.

Indian Response and Concerns:

• Addressing discrimination against all: India emphasized the need to address discrimination against all religions, not just Islam.
• Religious intolerance: They highlighted instances of religious intolerance and violence targeting Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, and other non-Abrahamic communities
• Inclusive approach: India urged the UN to adopt a more inclusive approach that acknowledges the diversity of religious discrimination and promotes pluralism.

Criticism of Pakistan and Addressing Religiophobia:

• Condemned resolution: Critics condemned Pakistan's resolution, citing its own record of religious persecution.
• Undermined credibility: Pakistan's history of discrimination against religious minorities, such as Ahmadis and Baha'is, undermines its credibility in championing the resolution.
• Rejecting all forms of religiophobia: Calls were made to reject all forms of religiophobia, including anti-Hindu, anti-Buddhist, and anti-Sikh sentiments, and to promote tolerance and religious freedom for all.