25th November 2024 (10 Topics)
1
Nov
2
Nov
4
Nov
5
Nov
6
Nov
7
Nov
8
Nov
9
Nov
11
Nov
12
Nov
13
Nov
14
Nov
15
Nov
16
Nov
18
Nov
19
Nov
20
Nov
21
Nov
22
Nov
23
Nov
25
Nov
Courts can’t fix agriculture, problems are far too complex
You must be logged in to get greater insights. click here to login
Context
A Supreme Court-appointed committee headed by Justice (retired) Nawab Singh has raised concerns over India's agrarian crisis, highlighting the need for legal sanctity to Minimum Support Prices (MSP) for farmers. While the committee’s observations are not binding, they are likely to influence ongoing Supreme Court hearings related to farmers' protests.
Agrarian Crisis and MSP
- Viability Crisis in Agriculture: The Indian agrarian economy is in a crisis, as evidenced by issues like farmer suicides, which reflect deep-rooted economic challenges in the sector.
- Limitations of MSP: The committee suggests that while MSP has been essential for ensuring food security, it cannot address deeper systemic issues like water scarcity, soil degradation, and the environmental impact of practices such as stubble burning.
- Localized Negative Impact: In states like Punjab, MSP has exacerbated problems such as water wastage and soil degradation, raising questions about its sustainability in the long term.
Broader Challenges in Indian Agriculture
- Labor Cost Reduction: To cope with rising labor costs, farmers are increasingly resorting to harmful practices like stubble burning, which have far-reaching environmental consequences.
- Need for Job Diversification: Generating employment opportunities outside agriculture is essential to alleviate the strain on the farming sector, although achieving this in a labor-abundant economy remains a complex challenge.
- Environmental Impact: Practices such as stubble burning, driven by cost-saving measures, contribute significantly to air pollution and are a direct fallout of the financial pressures on farmers.
Reforms for Sustainable Farming
- Political Dialogue for Change: A sustainable solution to the agrarian crisis requires a comprehensive political dialogue that includes all stakeholders to drive reforms and policy changes in the sector.
- Fiscal Space for Agricultural Transformation: There is a need to carve out fiscal resources to support long-term transformations in Indian farming, addressing issues such as sustainability, viability, and environmental conservation.
- Role of Courts: Courts should recognize that there are no simple solutions to the agrarian crisis and focus on facilitating constructive political and policy debates for a lasting resolution.
Practice Question:
Q. India’s agricultural sector is grappling with a viability crisis that is deeply intertwined with environmental degradation and socio-economic challenges. Discuss the limitations of the Minimum Support Price (MSP) scheme in addressing these issues and suggest a comprehensive approach to reforming the agrarian economy.
More Articles
Courses
Study
Notes
Home
Resources
More
