The discourse on labour reforms and the role of labour institutions in India's industrial relations system and labour market is under scrutiny, particularly regarding the need for evidence-based arguments and data-driven policymaking.
Challenges in Labour Reforms:
Lack of Evidence-based Dialogue: Despite the importance of social dialogue, the Indian Labour Conference (ILC) has been criticized for lacking evidence-based discussions and becoming a mere "talking shop."
Inadequate Labour Statistics: Labour statistics in India are not rigorous, lacking comprehensive data on various aspects of the industrial relations system and labour market.
Unsubstantiated Reform Arguments: Employers and neoliberal academics advocate for labour reforms based on anecdotal evidence and flawed studies, leading to the government's inclination towards introducing reform measures without empirical support.
Need for Data-driven Approaches:
Enhanced Data Collection: Trade unions should prioritize collecting relevant data on labour inspection, retrenchment/closure applications, and strikes to inform evidence-based arguments and challenge reform narratives.
Utilization of Labour Statistics: Labour unions must produce and utilize labour statistics to advocate for the protection of workers' rights and inform policy discussions.
Active Engagement with Academia: Trade unions should engage with academia to conduct research on the industrial relations system and labour market, fostering an evidence-based approach to labour reforms.