The cult of operational superiority, from Israel to India
Context:
Relying solely on military force to handle a threat works temporarily, but it fails when the enemy discovers vulnerability is dangerous for common people during any war.
Collapse of Israel's Security Policy
Historical Mirage: Israel's military prowess created an illusion of invincibility, but recent events reveal vulnerabilities and escalate risks.
Limited Air Campaigns: Israel's periodic attacks on Gaza aimed to weaken militant capabilities but lacked a long-term political plan.
Netanyahu's Strategy: Abandoning the two-state solution, Netanyahu's divisive tactics favored extremists, weakening the Palestinian Authority and perpetuating conflict.
The Pitfalls of Operational Superiority
Israel's Misconception: Relying on operational dominance, Israel overlooked the political roots of the conflict, allowing room for retaliatory strikes.
India's Approach to Pakistan: Similar to Israel, India prioritized military strength but neglected political resolution in dealing with Pakistan.
Kashmir Standoff: India's decision to end Jammu and Kashmir's autonomy signaled a non-negotiable stance, hindering potential diplomatic progress.
Embracing Political Solutions
Benefits of Dialogue: While not a cure-all, diplomacy can ease tensions, as seen in past rapprochements between historic adversaries.
Potential Gains for Pakistan: Engaging in dialogue can incentivize Pakistan to pursue economic stability and distance itself from extremist elements.
Addressing Broader Issues: Political processes can pave the way for confidence-building measures, cooperation on shared challenges, and economic growth.