2nd August 2024 (11 Topics)
1
Aug
2
Aug
3
Aug
5
Aug
6
Aug
7
Aug
8
Aug
9
Aug
10
Aug
12
Aug
13
Aug
14
Aug
15
Aug
16
Aug
17
Aug
19
Aug
20
Aug
21
Aug
22
Aug
23
Aug
24
Aug
26
Aug
27
Aug
28
Aug
29
Aug
30
Aug
31
Aug
Towards Disputes Irresolution
You must be logged in to get greater insights. click here to login
Context
The Indian government, through an office memorandum dated June 3, has outlined new guidelines for arbitration and mediation in domestic public procurement contracts, signaling a shift away from arbitration towards traditional court litigation. This change will significantly impact the legal system and economic environment.
Impact of Shifting from Arbitration:
- Increased Court Burden: The move away from arbitration will add significant pressure on an already overburdened legal system, leading to delays and increased court interference.
- Negative Repercussions: The decision will adversely affect private litigants, India's "Ease of Doing Business" ranking, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), and overall legal system efficiency.
- Litigation Process: The appeals process will become more extensive, potentially reaching the Supreme Court frequently due to government involvement, prolonging dispute resolution.
Concerns and Future Prospects:
- Historical Reforms: The 2015 amendments aimed to establish India as an arbitration hub, but subsequent amendments and the 2024 memorandum have reversed these gains, citing quick resolution as an issue.
- Quality of Representation: Arbitrations are often lost due to poor legal representation rather than corrupt arbitrators; solutions should focus on accreditation and training.
- Commercial Court Litigation: While arbitration diminishes, an increase in commercial court litigation may develop robust jurisprudence and demand for skilled trial lawyers, strengthening the legal ecosystem, albeit requiring substantial government investment.
Mains Question:
Q. In light of the recent shift away from arbitration in government contracts, critically assess the impact on India's legal and economic environment. Discuss whether increased commercial court litigation can offset the negative consequences of this shift.
More Articles
Courses
Study
Notes
Home
Resources
More
